Braucht niemanden zu scheren: NPI Licensing in German
نویسندگان
چکیده
NPIs have been studied intensely in several linguistic frameworks since Klima (1964). Since they may occur both in the scope of negation as well as in a variety of other semantically or pragmatically related environments (such as interrogatives, antecedents of conditionals, modifiers of superlative and universal NPs, complements of adversative predicates, to name a few), one very active and controversial research area is the detailed description of possible licensing contexts. One of the first steps towards such an NPI licensing theory was taken by Ladusaw (1980), who established that NPIs can only occur in downward-entailing (DE) contexts, building on an idea from Fauconnier (1975). In the face of a number of open questions concerning the standard Fauconnier-Ladusaw theory of NPIs, there has been further elaboration on this, as well as alternative analyses, some of which will be briefly sketched in Section 2 below. None of the semantic theories of NPIs have as yet been integrated into HPSG. The aim of the present paper is twofold. (1), we will present new representative data from German which highlight the kinds of distributional restrictions NPIs exhibit within the broader range of licensing domains known from the literature and indicated above, and (2), we will propose an architecture for an NPI licensing theory in HPSG.
منابع مشابه
Braucht niemanden zu scheren: A Survey of NPI Licensing in German
In this contribution we will argue that negative polarity is a collocational phenomenon that does not follow from other properties of the respective lexical elements. With German data as evidence, we will follow a proposal by van der Wouden and treat Negative Polarity Items (NPIs) as collocates which must be licensed by abstract semantic properties of their contexts. Using a collocation module ...
متن کاملLicensing German Negative Polarity Items in LTAG
Our paper aims at capturing the distribution of negative polarity items (NPIs) within lexicalized Tree Adjoining Grammar (LTAG). The condition under which an NPI can occur in a sentence is for it to be in the scope of a negation with no quantifiers scopally intervening. We model this restriction within a recent framework for LTAG semantics based on semantic unification. The proposed analysis pr...
متن کاملFive Types of Affective Contexts: Nonmonotonic NPI Licensers
1. Introduction In this paper, I show that there exist five-not only three-types of affective contexts which license negative polarity items (NPIs). There are two classes of nonmonotonic NPI licensers – stable and unstable-in addition to three kinds of downward entailing (DE) licensers that Zwarts (1993,1998) points out. The existence of covert 'only' is the key to NPI licensing by the unstable...
متن کاملNPI Licensing , Strawson Entailment , and Context Dependency KAI
The Fauconnier-Ladusaw analysis of negative polarity licensing (that NPIs are licensed in the scope of downward entailing operators) continues to be the benchmark theory of negative polarity. In this paper, I consider some of the moves that are needed to maintain its basic intuition in some recalcitrant arenas: negative polarity licensing by only, adversatives, superlatives, and conditionals. W...
متن کاملIllusory licensing effects across dependency types: ERP evidence.
A number of recent studies have argued that grammatical illusions can arise in the process of completing linguistic dependencies, such that unlicensed material is temporarily treated as licensed due to the presence of a potential licensor that is semantically appropriate but in a syntactically inappropriate position. A frequently studied case involves illusory licensing of negative polarity ite...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2006